Sarasota Real Estate Search

Advanced Search

Address Search

Home  >  Sarasota  >  Central Sarasota   >  Poinsettia Park

Poinsettia Park Real Estate for Sale

Sarasota - West of Trail


The “West of Trail” area is simple to define but to the casual observer, there are really no clear delineation of what subdivisions are where.  Our list of Poinsettia Park, is updated several times an hour so you are assured current and complete Sarasota MLS data. Situated between Tamiami Trail and Osprey Avenue on the streets of Bougainvillea, Magnolia, Oleander, and Rose, it is a quick zip to the downtown Sarasota, Siesta Key beach, and shopping.

The West of Trail area has two types of homes in this well kept, established, and affluent area of Sarasota.  One will be the older home that somewhere along the way was preserved and updated.  In some cases, you can find homes that are registered on the historic registry in Sarasota County. The other type of home is a newer home constructed in place of an older home at some point.  It all depends of what the original structure was and if bringing into the 20th (and now the 21st) century made sense.

Lots they are approximately 100’ wide are considered a “single lot” and 200 feet would be a “double” lot.  There is always a possibility that a double can be split but each case will have its own circumstances and governmental approval process.

Find Similar West of Trail Sarasota Homes for Sale
Poinsettia Park is west of the trail in Sarasota and see what real estate is selling for.
See the latest real estate market valuation report for Poinsettia Park - West of Trail - in Sarasota, FL

The streets are lined with mature Oaks and Palms. Sidewalks are on all streets.  Prices run the full gambit of what Sarasota has to offer.  If this location, and style of the area is for you, there is a home that can fit just about any budget.

If Poinsettia Park has your interest, be sure to get a better understanding of the values. We provide the recent sold listings along with the analysis that can help. Making smart buying and selling decisions start with reliable and current information and we put that at your fingertips. 

We have been selling homes in Sarasota for nearly two decades. Our local knowledge, along with timely SarasotaOne MLS information are keys to a successful transaction. Feel free to call or email us with your questions. We are always eager to help!

The Latest Poinsettia Park Listings

2318 Mcclellan Parkway, Sarasota image
2318 Mcclellan Parkway, Sarasota $840,000

Charm and enigma embrace this super clean and move-in ready McClellan Park home. West of Trail timeless colonial with an enchanting yard; stately and classic, yet full of...

  • 4 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • Mcclellan Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
1826 Clematis Street, Sarasota image
1826 Clematis Street, Sarasota $2,028,000

Under Construction. Relaxed Modern in Sarasota's most sought after area, "West of Trail". The Dominic is a new floor plan by Allegra Homes. All on one level this south fa...

  • 3 Beds
  • 3.5 Baths
  • Desoto Park For Petroutsa Bros SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
1701 Hashay Drive, Sarasota image
1701 Hashay Drive, Sarasota $969,000

McClellan Park - opportunity to live in one of Sarasota's most sought after neighborhoods, historic McClellan Park! This lot with its grand oaks and sprawling .44 acre c...

  • 3 Beds
  • 3.5 Baths
  • Mcclellan Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
2146 Mcclellan Parkway, Sarasota image
2146 Mcclellan Parkway, Sarasota $1,800,000

Under Construction. Another Courtyard Simply Modern Design. West of the Trail address. Southside school. Walking distance to everything! Sarasota School of Architecture i...

  • 3 Beds
  • 3.5 Baths
  • Mcclellan Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
1943 Morris Street, Sarasota image
1943 Morris Street, Sarasota $1,799,000

Coastal contemporary, luxurious, and sophisticated best describes this new residence. Perfectly situated in the prestigious West-of-Trail area on an oversized lot. The fl...

  • 3 Beds
  • 3.5 Baths
  • Hartsdale SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
1807 Oleander Street, Sarasota image
1807 Oleander Street, Sarasota $4,399,000

Transport yourself to the countryside of France where you may ensconce yourself behind the ivy-covered walls of this gated multi-level French chateau amidst the most glor...

  • 5 Beds
  • 7.5 Baths
  • Poinsettia Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
2330 Mietaw Drive, Sarasota image
2330 Mietaw Drive, Sarasota $1,695,000

Under Construction. Custom New Construction home West of the Trail in McClellan Park! This 3,267 SF custom home will be completed by end of 2020 and will be construc...

  • 5 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • Mcclellan Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
2263 Oriole Drive, Sarasota image
2263 Oriole Drive, Sarasota $899,000

Future homesite for your new home in McClellan Park, 15,100 Sq foot lot, just over 1/3 acre, tucked away and located on a quiet street just across from Sarasota Bay. This...

  • Mcclellan Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
2331 Mcclellan Parkway, Sarasota image
2331 Mcclellan Parkway, Sarasota $790,000 ▼

Historical cottage loaded with charm and remodeled in the last few years. Entering the home you are greeted with hardwood floors, high beamed ceilings and an amazing sto...

  • 3 Beds
  • 3 Baths
  • Mcclellan Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
1934 Bougainvillea Street, Sarasota image
1934 Bougainvillea Street, Sarasota $659,000 ▼

Rare find in desirable Poinsettia Park. Elegant West of Trail home, completely rebuilt in 2003. Short distance to sought after Southside School. Minutes from top ranked S...

  • 3 Beds
  • 2 Baths
  • Poinsettia Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
2231 Oriole Drive, Sarasota image
2231 Oriole Drive, Sarasota $3,295,000

Price based on appraised value. Enjoy comfort, style, and functional design in this impressive “West of Trail” home. Sited on an oversized lot in McClellan Park, one of t...

  • 5 Beds
  • 6.5 Baths
  • Mcclellan Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
3319 S Osprey Street, Sarasota image
3319 S Osprey Street, Sarasota $295,000 ▼

Build your dream home in this prime, West of the Trail location. 8,120 sq. ft. Surrounded by new construction and vintage charm, walk to Southside Village and school, ho...

  • Poinsettia Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code
1905 Goldenrod Street, Sarasota image
1905 Goldenrod Street, Sarasota $1,875,000 ▲

Brand new, ready for move in custom Florida Coastal inspired design from Classic Homes by Clayton. 4 bedrooms, bonus room, 4 baths, 3 car garage, pool w/ spa and large co...

  • 4 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • Poinsettia Park SubDv.
  • 34239 Zip Code

Address Search

Sell My Sarasota Real Estate

Central Sarasota Real Estate

Sarasota by Lifestyle

Bayfront Homes Gated Communities
Maintenance Free Golf Course Homes
Boating Communities Pool Homes

 Properties in Sarasota by Location

See all Bord Key Homes for Sale on the Map See all Lido Key Homes and Condos on the Map See all Venice Area Homes See All Homes and Condos for Sale in Nokomis and Osprey See all Palmer Ranch Homes for Sale See All South Sarasota Homes for Sale See all Central Sarasota Homes on the Map See all Mid Town Sarasota Homes See all Downtown Sarasota Properties for Sale on the Map See all Homes for Sale East of I-75 Sarasota on the Map See all Properties for Sale in Lakewood Ranch Florida See all Palm Aire Sarasota Homes on the Map See all Meadows Area Homes See all Homes for Sale in North Sarasota on the Map See all Homes and Condos in Siesta Key for Sale on the Map See all Longboat Key Real Estate for Sale on the Map

Browse listings on the map by area or choose from the links below.  Searching the MLS is so easy and you can save as many searches as you like.  We provide you with the newest lsitings and price changes daily by email.  Cancel anytime!

Central Sarasota by Price

Our Picks
under $100,000		 Our Picks
$100,000 - $200,000
More Picks
200,000 - $300,000		 More Picks
$400,000-$500,000
Luxury Homes
$500,000 - $750,000		 Luxury Homes
$750,000 - $1,000,000
Luxury / Waterfront
Over $1,000,000

Central Sarasota West - 34239

Central Sarasota North - 34232

Central Sarasota South - 34233

Nearby Sarasota Real Estate

Recent Blog Posts