• Home
  • Home Values
  • Sarasota
  • Venice
  • Manatee
  • Charlotte
  • Search
  • Videos
  • Blog
Login
941-357-1027

Sign in to your account

Need to reset your phone number?

Don't have an account with us?

Click here to sign up.

Bay Island Real Estate

Address Search

Bay Island Real Estate

Welcome to Bay Island – a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Florida’s vibrant coastal landscape! This delightful subdivision, located in the charming city of St. Petersburg, offers residents an idyllic blend of serene living and convenient access to the dynamic lifestyle that the Sunshine State is known for.

Bay Island is characterized by its picturesque waterfront views, lush landscaping, and a welcoming community atmosphere. The subdivision boasts a variety of beautifully designed homes, each exuding its own unique charm. Whether you’re seeking a cozy bungalow or a spacious waterfront property, Bay Island has something to suit every taste and lifestyle.

One of the standout features of this community is its impressive array of amenities. Residents enjoy access to a private clubhouse, heated swimming pools, tennis courts, and scenic walking paths that wind through the lush surroundings. Imagine sipping your morning coffee while watching the sunrise over the tranquil waters, or hosting a barbecue with friends and family in the inviting outdoor spaces.

Bay Island is not just about peaceful living; it’s also conveniently located near some of Florida’s best attractions. With just a short drive, you can explore the vibrant downtown St. Petersburg, filled with eclectic shops, gourmet restaurants, and cultural hotspots. The pristine beaches of the Gulf Coast are also within easy reach, offering endless opportunities for sun-soaked relaxation and outdoor adventures.

Discover the charm of Bay Island, where a serene lifestyle meets the excitement of coastal living. Come find your dream home in this enchanting community and experience the best that Florida has to offer!

Newest Listings in Bay Island

3482 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota image
3482 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota $6,975,000

Some homes are defined by their architecture, others by their setting. Casa Flamingo is a rare convergence of both, offering a distinctive vision of waterfront living on ...

  • 6 Beds
  • 7 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
546 Freeling Drive, Sarasota image
546 Freeling Drive, Sarasota $12,500,000

Pre-Construction. To be built. Expected to be complete in 3–4 months. Discover an extraordinary opportunity to own a new construction waterfront residence on an expansive...

  • 5 Beds
  • 7 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
700 Freeling Drive, Sarasota image
700 Freeling Drive, Sarasota $8,600,000

SWEEPING PANORAMIC WATER VIEWS!....MULTIPLE BOAT LIFTS!... GATED ESTATE RETREAT!...A Singular Offering Where PRIVACY and the Enjoyment of Waterfront Island Living create ...

  • 4 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
3607 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota image
3607 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota $4,950,000

Exceptional Waterfront in North Siesta Key's Bay Island Shores Community. Experience the best of coastal living in this 2005 custom built three-or four-bedroom, four full...

  • 3 Beds
  • 4 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
838 Norsota Way, Sarasota image
838 Norsota Way, Sarasota $4,190,000

Under Construction. To be complete in a few months. Discover timeless coastal elegance in this upcoming traditional-style new construction home, perfectly situated in the...

  • 5 Beds
  • 7 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
609 Norsota Way, Sarasota image
609 Norsota Way, Sarasota $8,500,000

An extraordinary opportunity to create a custom waterfront estate on coveted Norsota Way, where spectacular panoramic views stretch across Sarasota Bay to the downtown sk...

  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
604 Norsota Way, Sarasota image
604 Norsota Way, Sarasota $3,750,000

Welcome to an exceptional newly renovated residence in the highly coveted Bay Island neighborhood on north Siesta Key, where timeless coastal architecture and modern luxu...

  • 5 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
617 Siesta Drive, Sarasota image
617 Siesta Drive, Sarasota $849,900

A rare 0.30-acre homesite on Bay Island, the coveted gateway to Siesta Key, where homes seldom change hands and buildable land is almost impossible to find. This intimate...

  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
3799 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota image
3799 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota $17,650,000

Four Seasons Hotel in Bali or private estate? Set on more than an acre of coveted waterfront property along the prestigious north end of Siesta Key, this extraordinary Ba...

  • 4 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
3473 Hamilton Avenue, Sarasota image
3473 Hamilton Avenue, Sarasota $979,900

Some spend years searching for the perfect spot. This is it. A rare buildable lot on Bay Island—known as the gateway to Siesta Key, this intimate 169-home neighborhood at...

  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code
3820 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota image
3820 Flamingo Avenue, Sarasota $8,750,000 ▲

Under Construction. Move in before the 2026 holidays. Absolute best value for new construction on N Siesta Key in prime Bay Island location with easy access to downtown S...

  • 4 Beds
  • 6 Baths
  • Bay Island SubDv.
  • 34242 Zip Code

Address Search

Like or Share

View Bay Island Home Values

  • Bay Island Home Values

Browse Bay Island Homes by Property Type

  • Homes for Sale
  • Land for Sale

Browse Bay Island Homes by Property Description

  • One Story

Browse Bay Island Homes by Interior Features

  • Elevator

Browse Bay Island Homes by Water Frontage

  • Bay Front
  • Bay View
  • Beach Access
  • Beach View
  • Boatable Water
  • Lake Front
  • Sailboat Water

Browse Bay Island Homes by Water Extras

  • Bridges - No Fixed Bridges
  • Lift
  • No Wake Zone
  • Riprap
  • Sailboat Water
  • Seawall - Concrete

Browse Bay Island Homes by Community Extras

  • No Deed Restriction

Browse Bay Island Homes by Pool type

  • No Pool
  • Private

Browse Bay Island Homes by Property Style

  • Single Family

Browse Bay Island Homes by Frontage

  • Bay/Harbor
  • Canal - Saltwater
  • Intracoastal Waterway
  • Lagoon

Browse Bay Island Homes by High school

  • Sarasota High

Browse Bay Island Homes by Popular Features

  • Homes with New Construction
  • Home
  • Advanced Search
  • Custom Market Report
  • Sell My Sarasota Home
  • Buying
  • About Us
  • Featured Properties
  • Contact
  • Foreclosures
  • Blog
  • Our Terms of Use
  • RSS
  • Site Directory
  • Closing Costs
  • Resources

Sarasota Real Estate Group and SarasotaOne are wholly owned registered trademarks - USTPO #5,265,486
Sarasota Real Estate Group
Sarasota, FL
941-357-1027

Sarasota Real Estate listings are provided by StellarMLS.
Content by John Woodward, Broker
License # BK-684290
© 2004-2025 - All Rights Reserved

Sarasota and Nearby Homes for Sale

  • Lakewood Ranch
  • Venice
  • Venice - Island
  • Sarasota
  • Longboat Key
  • East Bradenton
  • University Park
  • Palmer Ranch
  • Downtown
  • Parrish
  • South Sarasota
  • Central Sarasota
  • Manatee County
  • Pinellas County
  • Sarasota County
IDX Real Estate Websites by
• Accessibility • Terms • Privacy